With America #2, writer Gabby Rivera, artist Joe Quinones, and artist Ming Doyle continue the sense of fun and excitement that marked the first issue. If the idea of a TED style talk given by Lunella Lafayette (aka the smartest person in the Marvel universe who just so happens to be a nine year old girl) doesn’t make you grin a tiny bit, you’re probably reading the wrong book. As a whole, the issue is a celebration of girl power, seen through a bright, fun lens. However, some of the problems from the first issue still remain: most notably the pacing. As soon as America returns home from World War II, she’s thrown right into a B-Plot involving prep school prospective students. We get one page of teasing out further plots and one page of America reacting to the past issue and a half, both of which are unfortunately ‘tell over show.’ America talks a LOT. Since she’s the protagonist of the series, it’s understandable that she would have more dialogue and be comparatively more talkative than she was in Young Avengers—someone’s got to drive the plot, after all, and at least for Young Avengers, that someone wasn’t America. But the page where America reflects on her current state of life feels needlessly wordy. It feels like the sort of thing that America would tell a supporting cast member.
Thankfully, Rivera, Quinones, and Doyle do a wonderful job building up America’s supporting cast, fleshing them out from their brief encounters in #1. That one page of teasing out further plots focuses on Professor Douglas, America’s ‘Intergalactic Revolutionaries and You’ professor. America becomes closer friends with X’Andria, the leader of one of the university’s sororities. Already, the characters provide a wonderful contrast with their ideas of family.
Thankfully, Lisa (America’s ex-girlfriend) shows up again–unfortunately, she’s being held captive as a hostage by the Chavez Guerrillas, a group of young women who idolize America to an unhealthy extent. The Chavez Guerrillas are led by Imani, a girl who America rescued in the first issue. I’m always a bit wary of the trope of ‘fandom and idolization turning people evil,’ especially since part of the reason America Chavez got a solo series in the first place is because of her vocal fandom. It remains to be seen how the book walks the line between ‘good fan’ and ‘bad fan.’
Obviously from that last paragraph, there are a lot of plots being juggled and a lot of balls in the air. Some of them come at the expense of others: the World War II part of the issue seemed mostly to be a set piece so plot points could be dropped. Aside from punching Hitler and a gratuitous yet appreciated Peggy Carter cameo, the book doesn’t really play with the World War II setting as much as it could have–and now that America is back at Sotomayor University, I doubt we’ll be revisiting the setting to begin with. Still, with America #2, you can tell the creative team is starting to find their feet, making a fun, exciting, and enthralling book
Advertisement